Inaccessible Pandan Perdana

Pandan Perdana
Pandan Perdana – Narrow road and an inaccessible walkway.
File photo dated May 21, 2006.

There was a slight drizzle. It was dark. The tree just below the street lamp shaded the illumination. It was ten past eight. It was an accident waiting to happen. And it happened. Wuan was pushing me along the walkway from the shops back to her house after dinner yesterday. As always, she would slightly lift my wheelchair and manoeuvre around one particular lamppost along the way because there was barely enough space between that lamppost and kerb to allow my wheelchair to pass.

Pandan Perdana
Pandan Perdana – Lamppost in the center of walkway.
File photo dated May21, 2006.

While she was lifting the wheelchair, the right front caster went off the edge of the kerb. She desperately tried to pull it back onto the walkway. It was an impossible task even if she had the strength. She lost her balance. The back wheel went off the kerb as well. In a split second, my wheelchair tilted right, dropped onto the road and landed on its side. I was thrown onto the road by the impact. I could feel the rough surface of the road scraping against some parts of my body and the stinging pain that ensued. From her muffled voice, I knew that Wuan fell onto the road too.

Pandan Perdana
Pandan Perdana – The narrow space between lamppost and kerb
File photo dated May21, 2006.

She got up and kept apologising, “I am so sorry darling.” I could see the panic in her face. She had turned a few shades paler. I could see the fear in her eyes when she asked if I was injured. I kept reassuring her that I was all right and asked if she injured herself. Nevertheless, at the back of my mind, what I feared most was being run over by a passing vehicle, especially by a bus, as I was lying helpless on the road in the semi-darkness.

Pandan Perdana
Pandan Perdana – Car parked on the walkway.
File photo dated May21, 2006.

A beat-up van passed us by as I lay sprawled on the road. It stopped a short distance away. Two men got out from the van and came running towards us. I could hear the sounds of a motorcycle stopping behind me. In those few seconds of confusion, someone asked how he could help. A man wearing a helmet was just behind me, helping Wuan with the wheelchair. The two men from the van were standing in front of me.

Pandan Perdana
Pandan Perdana – Another car parked on the damaged walkway opposite.
File photo dated May21, 2006.

I instructed Wuan to put the brakes on and push back the armrest on my side to make it easier to put me back on the wheelchair. Someone held my right arm, another my left, and with a single heave both placed me back onto the wheelchair. Before Wuan and I could thank them enough, they had already left – the van and the motorcycle melting into the distance and darkness. Without them, Wuan would not have been able to get me back onto the wheelchair.

Pandan Perdana
Superficial wounds on my left palm and right forearm.

“Are you all right? Did you injure yourself?” I asked Wuan, worried that in the ensuing commotion, she had not realised that she was injured. She did a cursory check. There were some minor scrapes on her leg from falling onto the road. I lost some skin and flesh on my left hand, the result of attempting to break my fall with it. There were also some superficial wounds on my right arm, elbow, leg and foot. My right triceps ached. I must have pulled that muscle when I fell.

Pandan Perdana
Close-up of the cuts on my right forearm.

What pained me most were not the minor injuries to Wuan and myself but the stupidity of planting a lamppost right in the center of the walkway. It does not take much intelligence to know that walkways are for pedestrians. They are to prevent pedestrians from walking on the road and endangering their own lives and those of motorists. Here, we have a lamppost that stuck out like a sore thumb blocking easy access of the walkway. Walkways are roads for pedestrains. Would anybody in his or her right frame of mind install a lamppost right in the middle of a public road? Wuan could have been seriously injured. The fall could have broken a bone or two in me or I could have killed because the engineers and architects at Majlis Perbandaran Ampang Jaya and Tenaga Nasional Berhad did not see it fit to relocate the obstructing lamppost. Idiots!

Pandan Perdana
Close-up of the wound on my left palm.

Walkways in many parts of Malaysia are a hazard. Never mind that they are devoid of kerb ramps at the ends for accessibility. If there are kerb ramps, most time they are not constructed to be functional. Some are in a state of disrepair with uneven surfaces while some have uncovered holes that could cause a fracture if a leg was trapped in it. Every time I want to get onto the walkways to reduce the risks of being hit by a vehicle on the road, I needed assistance. Malaysian kerbs are being constructed higher and higher to prevent vehicles from being parked on it. This has greatly inconvenienced those who have mobility problems and are unable to climb the 6-inch height, especially the elderly. Then, there is the danger of falling from misstepping on the sudden drop at the end of the walkways when getting off them.

Pandan Perdana
Close-up of the wound on my right elbow.

Very often, walkways are adorned with street furniture that causes great inconvenience to disabled persons, namely wheelchair users and the visually impaired. Refuse bins, traffic signs, post boxes, lampposts and even trees are left to obstruct the flow. Apart from that, we have to contend with inconsiderate drivers, motorcyclists and trishaw riders who park their vehicles indiscriminately on the walkways. Hawkers and shopkeepers are culprits to such inconveniences too with their carts and goods.

Pandan Perdana
Close-up of the wounds on my right leg.

Now, Wuan and I have to think of ways and means to go to the shops without getting on the road and risk being hit by passing vehicles or get on the offending walkway and risk falling off it again. For wheelchair users, safe options are very limited or even non-existent. That is how much we are worth to the government and the local authorities. According to Wikipedia, Malaysia has the best expressway network in Southeast Asia and is ranked third in Asia. That is something that I have always been proud of as a Malaysian. However, in my eyes, Malaysia ranks zero in terms of accessible walkways. How ironic.

Note: The photos taken on May 21, 2006 were for an entry I wanted to write on inaccessibility in Pandan Perdana. The accident expedited the process.

Related entry:
A Day At Pandan Indah – Pandan Indah is also under the jurisdiction of Majlis Perbandaran Ampang Jaya.

Inaccessible Sungai Dua


Braving the traffic at Jalan Sungai Dua.
Photo by Wuan.

One of the key concepts of Independent Living for people with disabilities is that they should live in the community instead of in institutions. Humans are social creatures. Disabled persons are no less that. We want to make friends, enjoy a glass of teh tarik at the local mamak stalls or a movie at the cinemas, and generally do everything that the non-disabled do.


Dangerous and inaccessible walkway at Jalan Pekaka.
Photo by Wuan.

One of the main barriers of community living for disabled persons is accessibility. Walkways are constructed without kerb ramps for wheelchairs and the mobility impaired and tactile tiles for the blind and visually impaired. Very often, road signs, lamp posts or post boxes are left smack in the middle of walkways. That not only impedes the passage of wheelchairs but poses a potent danger to the blind when they walk right into it.


Cars parked by the road side at Lorong Pekaka Satu.
Photo by Wuan.

Yesterday, I needed to go to the bank. It is about 1 km from my apartment. Wuan accompanied me. We took the road along Jalan Pekaka, then cut through Makro and down Jalan Sungai Dua towards USM. All along the way, we had to brave speeding traffic. Jalan Pekaka is notorious for traffic accidents and I was half expecting to be hit by a vehicle the entire journey.


Jalan Sungai Dua.
Photo by Wuan.

This fear was exacerbated by a story related to me when I was at Bangkok. Many parts of Bangkok are not accessible. And I noticed that the cars there were being driven at breakneck speed. I asked someone if there ever was an accident involving a wheelchair. Sadly, the answer was positive. A man on a wheelchair was hit by a truck on the road. The truck driver could not see the wheelchair from where he was. The impact threw the man on the wheelchair quite a distance. He was killed instantly.


A flight of stairs was built over a ramp here.
Photo by Wuan.

Crossing to the other side the road at Jalan Sungai Dua was another hazard. Without a pedestrian crossing, we had to practically run across the road to get to the other side. When we reached the bank, I faced another problem. A flight of stairs was built over where a steep ramp once was. Wuan wanted to pull my wheelchair up the steps but I refused. It would be dangerous to her and me if she were to lose her grip or miss a step. I waited by the side of the road while Wuan went into the bank.


Waiting outside the bank under the hot sun.
Photo by Wuan.

The sun was extremely hot. People with spinal cord injury like me have problems regulating body temperature and sweat. I began to feel dizzy as I waited under the blistering heat. Fortunately, the bank has some very helpful and courteous staff. They came out to get me to sign the forms and quickly completed the transaction. The journey back was equally as scary. At times like this, I wished I was back in Japan with her wide walkways and thoughtful drivers.


Inaccessible narrow walkway that even the non-disabled had problems using.
Photo by Wuan.

That is one of the reasons why many people do not see disabled persons out and about. With such dangers lurking at every street corner, we have no choice but stay in or look for alternative transport. Not many of us can afford alternative transport though. Taxis are expensive. Buses are not accessible. Those whose livelihood depended on going out in the street jungle know the risks and still go out anyway. What choice do they have?